Need help with your Assignment?

Get a timely done, PLAGIARISM-FREE paper
from our highly-qualified writers!

Toxic Leadership Action Plan

Toxic Leadership Action Plan

Toxic leadership combines self-centered behaviors, motivations, and attitudes that adversely affect the subordinates, the performance mission, and the organization (Reed & Olsen, 2010). A toxic leader lacks concern for the environment and that of others, which has long-term and short-term negative effects. Such a leader operates from an acute self-interest and inflated self-worth (Armitage, 2015). Craig & Kaiser (2012) assert that a toxic leader will use behavior that is dysfunctional and in a consistent manner to unfairly punish, coerce, intimidate, or deceive others for their selfish gain. The prolonged use of negative leadership in influencing others undermines followers’ will, potential, and initiative, eventually destroying their morale (Mehta & Maheshwari, 2013).

Are you seeking an authentic version of the “Toxic Leadership Action Plan essay”? Contact us.

A case study of Toxic Leadership: Identifying the Toxic Leader

Most organizations have leaders that followers can easily interact with and who make work life more fulfilling. However, some organizations have leaders who make employees dread going to work or even opt to quit their jobs in search of better opportunities (Walumbwa et al., 2011). That said, I would like to bring to the attention of the Human Resources department one of the managers who fit the latter description. The person in question is the Customer Satisfaction (CS) manager, who has consistently displayed the characteristics of a toxic leader. His behavior has continually affected the people he works with at the department and the organization. The high employee turnover experienced in the last 17 months can be largely attributed to the CS manager.

Some decisions by the manager have proven that he places his self-interest above that of others in the department. For starters, the manager does not recognize the team member’s contribution to the department. In most incidences, the manager will, during the organization board meetings, take credit for ideas he did not come up with or implement. An example is the recent customer reward program that the department successfully implemented, which resulted in a significant increase in the organization’s number of clients in the last quarter. Two subordinates in the department fronted the idea, planned it out by the team, and implemented it by the same group alongside the Finance, Marketing, and IT departments. The Customer Satisfaction manager took all the credit without ever mentioning the contribution of the team members. The organization even rewarded him with the Employee of the Year Award, while those who did the hard work went unnoticed. This was very demotivating and eventually led to a quarter of the employees resigning.

Other toxic characteristics that the manager has exhibited include: openly arguing with employees in front of the customers, verbal abuse and esteem bashing of employees, instilling fear in interns who often dread reporting to work, vehemently opposing any changes, and being irritable at the suggestion of any modification in customer service provision. Furthermore, the manager sets unrealistic goals for the department, resulting in workloads piling up, thus, setting the department and organization for failure, among others.

How to Repair the Rift After Removal of The Toxic Leader

The first and most urgent action that needs to be taken by HR is to investigate the allegations above without victimizing any of the employees that voluntarily give information. If the allegations are true, Kusy & Holloway (2009) assert that this report also suggests that the CS manager be relieved of his duties immediately. However, firing the toxic leader is easy; the rift must be repaired (Campbell & Brown, 2015). Repairing such a rift can be achieved through a series of steps.

The HR department must evaluate the organization’s culture to determine if any pressures are exerted on leadership to succeed (Frost, 2009). These organizational pressures to grow can transform the leaders to be toxic or cause others to tolerate other people’s harmful behavior. The human resource will have to hire third parties to assess senior leadership performance and culture to avoid bias. Further, a succession plan will need to be created. In this case, the toxic leader will leave a gap in the succession as several of his subordinates that could have taken up the job have already resigned for other opportunities (Mansell et al., 2017). The HR will offer training and development opportunities to departmental employees to groom an appropriate leader to take up the vacant position. An alternative will be to hire another manager from an outside source but still conduct succession training for future needs (Greene, 2016). Rewards and bonuses should also be linked to employee well-being and continuous growth. Lastly, Owens et al. (2015) propose that behavioral training for leaders should be conducted frequently and keenly monitored.

Desired Qualities of an Interim Leader

The employees at the Customer Satisfaction department are likely to be demotivated after working under their toxic manager. Their morale at work must be boosted and their self-worth enhanced (Webster et al., 2016). To this end, an ideal interim leader that will grow the team from its low standing to one that performs without fear and intimidation will need to be appointed. The new leader must possess qualities that benefit the group and the organization.

The new team leader will have to be a very skilled communicator. Effective communication is critical as it is the foundation of motivation (Berger, 2014). It will help the manager know how different tasks are performed and improve performance. Communication will help in decision-making and aid in identifying various courses of action. People’s attitudes will also be built as well-informed people tend to have a better attitude towards work, leadership, and team members (Berger, 2014).

Making time for employees will also be an important thing to do. The new leader should possess listening skills accompanied by constructive criticism and positive affirmation (Bethel, 2012). When employees approach the leader with an issue or a fresh idea on doing things differently, they will need to actively listen and give their honest and unbiased opinion and the necessary resources to actualize the concept if deemed viable and profitable to the department and organization. If the vision is successfully actualized, the leader should be the first to recognize the main contributors and front them for an award for their achievement (Berendt et al., 2012). In conclusion, the new leader should work at mending the broken work environment in the department, lay a new and viable foundation, and follow this by growing productive employees while impressing their well-being.

Other Related Post: Theory of Justice As Fairness


Armitage, A. (2015). The dark side: The poetics of toxic leadership. Advances in Developing Human Resources17(3), 376-390.

Campbell, M., & Brown, B. A. (2015). Toxic Leader Transition Mini Case Study: Yahoo! Inc. 2009-2012.

Craig, S. B., & Kaiser, R. B. (2012). Destructive leadership. The Oxford Handbook of Administration, 439-454.

Kusy, M., & Holloway, E. (2009). Toxic workplace!: Managing poisonous personalities and their systems of power. John Wiley & Sons.

Mansell, M., Lane, T., Thomas-Johnson, G. A. R. W. A. Y., & Lorenzo, d. (2017). Toxic leadership: a systemic approach to shift from reactive to proactive solutions. Air command and staff college Maxwell Air Force Base United States.

Mehta, S., & Maheshwari, G. C. (2013). A Consequence of Toxic Leadership on Employee Job Satisfaction and Organizational Commitment. Journal of Contemporary Management Research8(2).

Owens, B. P., Wallace, A. S., & Waldman, D. A. (2015). Leader narcissism and follower outcomes: The counterbalancing effect of leader humility. Journal of Applied Psychology100(4), 1203.

Reed, G. E., & Olsen, R. A. (2010). Toxic leadership: Part Deux. Army Combined Arms Center Fort Leavenworth KS Military Review.

Webster, V., Brough, P., & Daly, K. (2016). Fight, flight, or freeze Common responses for followers coping with toxic leadership. Stress and Health32(4), 346-354.


We’ll write everything from scratch


Week 4 – Assignment: Compose An Action Plan


Compose an action plan to present to HR which addresses how you would replace a toxic leader in your organization.

Toxic Leadership Action Plan

Toxic Leadership Action Plan

Discuss which attributes led you to identify this person as a toxic leader. Discuss how you will repair the rift caused by the leader after removal. As part of this plan, create an outline for the ideal leader who can serve in an interim capacity to help transition from toxic leadership.

Your action plan should demonstrate thoughtful consideration of the ideas and concepts presented in the course and provide new thoughts and insights relating directly to this topic. Your response should reflect graduate-level writing and APA standards. Be sure to adhere to Northcentral University’s Academic Integrity Policy.

References: Include a minimum of five scholarly references.

Order Solution Now