Need help with your Assignment?

Get a timely done, PLAGIARISM-FREE paper
from our highly-qualified writers!

How do you write a Critical Appraisal?

critical appraisal

Critical appraisal is much like breaking something down and judging it to see if it’s good or not. It’s some kind of report card on something with grades on how well it’s written, how good the evidence is, or if the evidence makes sense. Just as when you write a book report or deliver a presentation in class, you have to look, therefore, at just what it is you are speaking about and decide whether it is good or bad.

A critical appraisal usually deals with the close reading of the material to define its strengths and weaknesses within a literary work or research paper. You will want to read the material carefully while making notes on important points, arguments, and evidence made by the author. Important is the identification of the author’s main thesis and whether it is underpinned with sound evidence. You will also be required to critically assess the quality of writing and the techniques of research which the author used.

In your critical review, be sure to demonstrate how you come to your overall judgment by providing supporting evidence and examples. This could include direct quotes from the work, references to other documents or publications, or even your own observations and interpretations. Also, it is important that any problems you find are presented with recommendations for improvement and not just identified. Our assignment writing help will hone your writing prowess significantly.

JBI Critical Appraisal Tool

Apparently, JBI’s Critical Appraisal Tool has been quite useful among learners and researchers for the appraisal of different research study qualities. In this sense, a structured method is available to explore the strengths and weaknesses of a study, which may build an ability in a user to identify its reliability or validity in the findings. It enables readers to decide more judiciously whether to rely on the results of a study and apply them in their own research and practice with the help of the JBI Critical Appraisal Tool.

Furthermore, the JBI Critical Appraisal Tool assists students and researchers by stepping them through the information that they may have at their disposal. Therefore, this tool used in making a critique of any research study helps one appreciate the strength and weaknesses portrayed by a study toward making sound decisions.

Critical Appraisal Checklist

The checklist for critical appraisal focuses on study design, sample size, methodology, results, and conclusions. All these aspects are critically appraised to enable the readers to come up with their judgment regarding bias or defects in order to frame their own judgment on the overall value of the research. Critical appraisal checklists are basic tools used by students and researchers to appraise the information’s credibility; therefore, it helps an individual in making an informed decision about the reliability of the information.

Using a critical appraisal checklist, readers will further be in a position to pinpoint the strengths and weakness of a study and as such make prudent choices or decisions on how to apply these findings towards one’s knowledge or practice accurately.

JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist

The JBI appraisal checklist, as a tool, guides a person in making an estimate of whether or not the scientific research can be trusted. It questions matters like if the study had enough people, whether the findings are reliable, or that if all important factors were taken into consideration by the researchers. Supposedly, it means the questioning form of these, therefore enable us to know if a study is good enough or not and if we can really trust what it says. That is why tools of such kind are so indispensable: one has to make informed and smart decisions based on valid information.

How do practicing nurses participate in critical appraisal of research

First are the practice nurses who ensure the best in care that should be assured to patients. They do so by executing critical appraisal, assessing and reviewing research studies and evidence toward the best action for patient care. This can help keep the nurses informed of information and practice in health care so that care, most effective and based on evidence, can be given to the patient.

There is a need for developing analytical strategies out of the public health research and evidence for critical nurses, who have to know the implications found and apply them in the practices involved in patient care. This means that professional nurses would be very good researchers, with associated expertise in methods and related statistics, which empower them to assess the validity and reliability of such research studies. Through the appraisal process, the nurses also develop their critical thinking and decision-making skills, key components in offering the best practice of patient care.

How to cite JBI Critical Appraisal Tools

This is where you would have used the JBI critical appraisal tools in your paper writing. One is to ensure that the tool is cited properly in any paper for the purpose of crediting the author and showing where you got the information used. In citing a JBI critical appraisal tool, ensure the author’s name, the title of the tool, the publication date, website, or database from which it was retrieved. For example: JBI Foundation. (2018) JBI Critical Appraisal Checklist for Analytical Cross Sectional Studies. Retrieved from

How to critically appraise

Critical appraisal is a deep and thoughtful consideration of something. When you critically appraise something, you need to look into all the different parts and see whether they make sense. You also have to consider why this thing is so important and how it fits into the bigger picture. To critically appraise something, therefore, it may turn out necessary one asks questions, looks for information, and listens to different opinions: this would be almost like being a detective at work to work out the truth. Careful consideration in your appraisal will ensure you have understood something completely and are able to make sound decisions regarding it.

How to critically appraise a Meta analysis

Critical appraisal of a meta-analysis can sound like a gargantuan task but is really not that hard once you get to know what it is that you’re after. Start by checking the methods of the study: do they appear adequate and clear? Make sure that the researchers included all relevant studies and did not just pick and choose which ones to use. Look at the results too: do they seem logical, fairly convincing? Lastly, think about whether the conclusions drawn by the researchers are valid in light of the evidence that they present. You can critically appraise a meta-analysis and thus determine to trust it for information, by bearing such questions in mind or having those elements at back of your head.

How to critically appraise a Journal Article

There is the initial step that one has to make before undertaking anything in critiquing a journal. The credibility of the author and the source of the article needs to be identified. Find the credentials backing up the author, and it has to be identified if the journal is peer-reviewed. One should then read the abstract and introduction in order to understand what the main points of the article are. One should then consider if the methodology part shows the research was carried out properly and the results are reliable. Attend to the discussion and conclusion that indicate whether the findings really do back up what the author claims. Finally, consider the implication of the research and if it contributes to the field.

How to critically appraise a Medical Journal Article

A medical journal article can be critically appraised by investigating the study design, sample size, and results in the determination of the validity and reliability of the results. Start with reading the abstract to get the major statements being brought out in the article; thereafter, proceed to the introduction section in trying to find out whether the study is targeting at a gap in the knowledge. View the methods section to find out whether the study was really done well and in an ethical manner, and then view the results: do they seem to be supporting the conclusion? Check limitations and whether the findings are generalizable to others. Lastly, check the references to see if the authors have cited reliable sources.

How to critically appraise a randomized controlled trial

Important questions that will be answered when you try to figure out whether a randomized controlled trial is good or not include: Have they got biases which might affect the results? This would then be followed by the determination of whether the sample size used in the research is large enough to have results that are credible. Also, the way in which the study was set up and whether there were any faults in the setting up of the study is important. You will see whether the results were one that is really meaningful—could it help doctors make decisions on treatments? By asking these questions, you can be a smart critic and figure out if a randomized controlled trial is worth paying attention to.


Critical appraisal skill in writing is at most importance within the health and research field. The critical appraisal with provided resources like the JBI critical appraisal tool, while adopting these structural steps, would assist you judiciously in the appraisal of the research article. Remember that proper critical appraisal helps improve ways in which findings are applied to practice.

For more resources and tools that will help you in achieving victory over critical appraisal, visit for affordable prices. Join us in the course of impacting evidenced-based practice and making informed research decisions. Our accounting homework help will make you shine in your respective accounting field.

Order Solution Now