Case Analysis – Protecting Minors from Labor Exploitation
Moral Issues
The proposal seeks to impose restrictions on child labor to protect the rights and well-being of young people. It draws from different moral premises, including protecting minors, improving education access, balancing economic necessities against protections, and autonomy based on developmental capability (Vincent Ryan Ruggiero, 2015). As per the proposal, young people below 21 years are subjected to varying labor protections to improve their welfare.
Firstly, the proposal intends to protect minors from exploitation. Children and teenagers are vulnerable to exploitation due to their age and developmental stage. They cannot make informed decisions independently, hence the need to be protected by authorities (Vincent Ryan Ruggiero, 2015). Thus, preventing minors’ participation in hazardous industries and limiting their working hours will protect them from mental and physical harm.
Secondly, the proposal takes into account socio-economic diversity among different families. In certain households, children may be required to actively participate in income-generating activities to complement what their parents make (Vincent Ryan Ruggiero, 2015). To that end, the proposal avers that children below 18 years may work to support their households, but working hours should be limited to protect them from harm. Overall, these protections are designed to allow children and teenagers access to educational opportunities and to reach an age where they can make autonomous decisions.
Parties Involved and their Interests
Some of the parties involved in the labor protection proposal include advocacy and non-governmental organizations (NGOs). Advocacy groups and NGOs seek to ensure the health and overall well-being of minors. Also, government agencies and policymakers are responsible for drafting laws that will be used to protect minors from labor exploitation. Other parties include businesses/employers, parents/guardians, and young workers.
Common Ground
Despite the need to protect minors from labor exploitation, there is a need to consider the practical needs of certain industries. Policymakers should avoid restrictions that will hinder youths from acquiring essential skills safely. For instance, setting up apprenticeship programs that will enable children and teenagers to learn these skills will be helpful (Nesi et al., 2016). Such programs will enable minors to learn useful skills just in time in preparation for the real world.
References
Nesi, G., Nogler, L., & Pertile, M. (2016). Child labour in a globalized world: a legal analysis of ILO action. Routledge.
Vincent Ryan Ruggiero. (2015). Thinking critically about ethical issues. Mcgraw-Hill Education.
ORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HERE
We’ll write everything from scratch
Question
Case Analysis – Protecting Minors from Labor Exploitation
The title for my paper should be: Case Analysis 1
For this module, you are required to complete a Written Case Analysis of approximately 200 words. Please read Thinking Critically About Ethical Issues, Case 5, pp. 167-168. Identify the moral issue(s) and the parties involved, and infer their interests; discuss the case in terms of finding common ground in the diversity of interests you identify.