Response -Navigating the Difficulties in Child Abuse Investigations

Response -Navigating the Difficulties in Child Abuse Investigations

Responding to Jordan Klein

Hello Jordan,

Great work with your post. I concur that the court processes when it comes to child maltreatment cases can be extremely challenging. One aspect of these processes is the emotional complexity that comes with them. Child maltreatment cases often involve highly emotional and sensitive issues, including abuse, neglect, and trauma. This emotional complexity can make it difficult for all parties involved, including the child, the accused perpetrator, and even court officials, to remain objective and focused on legal proceedings. Another aspect is that child witnesses may be required to testify in court, which can be traumatic and intimidating for them. Children may struggle to accurately recall and articulate their experiences, leading to challenges in presenting their testimony effectively. Furthermore, defense attorneys may try to discredit or confuse child witnesses during cross-examination, further complicating the process. This is especially true in some cases where there may be limited physical evidence of maltreatment, particularly in cases of emotional or psychological abuse. For instance, Grégoire et al. (2020) showed that trauma can lead to loss of memory in abused children. Accordingly, this can make it challenging to build a strong case against the accused, especially if there are no eyewitnesses or corroborating evidence to support the child’s allegations. Lastly, I also agree that closing a case after successfully finding a family to look after the child is the easiest part of the case.

References

Grégoire, L., Gosselin, I., & Blanchette, I. (2020). The impact of trauma exposure on explicit and implicit memory. Anxiety, Stress, & Coping, 33(1), 1-18.

Responding to Jordan Klein

Hello Kaitlyn,

Great post. I agree that making initial contact with a child who has been maltreated is difficult. Such a child will likely have emotional and traumatic distress, which will not only make it hard for them to trust but also affect their ability to communicate effectively with authorities or other adults, making it challenging to establish rapport and trust during initial contact. In addition, there is the issue of trauma bonding, which you have mentioned through manipulation and control. Abusers often use manipulation and control tactics to maintain power and control over their victims, making it hard to get abused children to turn on their abusers (Sarfarazi, 2022). I also agree that a child maltreatment case would be easy when it comes to court testifying, but only if there is enough evidence to convict the abuser. Testifying can become challenging, especially if all there is a child’s testimony since the defendant’s lawyers can easily discredit the child as a child is no match to a lawyer. Therefore, a case becomes easy only if there is more evidence, including multiple eyewitnesses, physical evidence like photographic, audio, or video evidence, and DNA evidence in cases of sexual abuse.

References

Sarfarazi, M. P. (2022). Narcissistic-psychopathic manipulation – Part II of: Leadership or chaos effectuated by an avaricious desire for tyrannous manipulation and control – Spiritual Psychology 101 series. www.academia.edu. https://www.academia.edu/77565440/Narcissistic_Psychopathic_Manipulation_Part_II_of_Leadership_or_Chaos_Effectuated_by_Avaricious_Desire_for_Tyrannous_Manipulation_and_Control_Spiritual_Psychology_101_Series

ORDER A PLAGIARISM-FREE PAPER HERE

We’ll write everything from scratch

The original post is attached.

Please respond to these two discussion posts.
Question: After reading Chapter 4 of your textbook, discuss what you believe would be the most difficult part of an investigation of child abuse/neglect and why; initial contact with victim(s), initial contact with the alleged perpetrator(s), removal of children from their parents/home, testifying in court, placing children in foster care, and/or closing a case. What do you think would be the easiest part and why?

Response -Navigating the Difficulties in Child Abuse Investigations

Discussion 1:
Jordan Klein (She/Her)

After reading Chapter 4 of our textbook, I believe there would be many complex parts of an investigation of child abuse/neglect. However, the most challenging part would be testifying in court. The reason why this would be difficult is because of the many different types of court processes. These are sectioned into two categories, one depending on whether it is an emergency custody order. The court processes for a nonemergency custody hearing are an initial hearing, adjudication hearing, dispositional hearing, and review hearing (Royse & Griffiths, 2020, p.71). The court processes for the emergency custody hearing are emergency removal, adjudication, dispositional, review, permanency, and termination of parental rights (Royse & Griffiths, 2020, p. 72). Throughout both processes, there is any chance that the custodial parent can have custody of the child again. This process can be frightening to the children throughout the process as they have to live through their trauma again and are unsure of their future.
Although throughout the child investigation, there is a tricky part, there is hope that, in the end, the child will be saved and will have the chance to live a long, fulfilled life. The easiest part of an investigation of child abuse/neglect would be closing the case. After initial contact with the victim(s), initial contact with the alleged perpetrator(s), removal of children from their parents/home, and testifying in court, we as social workers can come to the best conclusion, we can help the child as best as reasonably possible. When the case is closed, there is the satisfaction of helping another family and giving them the ability to live the life they deserve. Although this is wishful thinking, there is always a possibility that although the case is close, we might not believe they should return to their family or go to foster care. This uncertainty is a factor in being a social worker, but with our education, resources, and team around us, there is a higher chance that we will be able to help the victim(s).